+24

Is it OK to downvote those who come and just say "Hi" in Q and A threads?

Is downvoting good etiquette for this? It could just be an ignorant user doing this and not a spammer.

4/13/2019 6:53:37 AM

Sonic

34 Answers

New Answer

+20

I should not downvote the question of a new user coming in. If he or she misbehaves, there is a need to downvote. Apart from this, I do not even know.

+17

For an experienced user - with a gold or platinum badge, I ll probably give a downvote with a note. But not for beginners as they will leave this community. I d simply say Hi and tell this is not the right place

+14

In my opinion, yes, it is OK to do so. Even more, i think it should be done; for the most important reason: To show to those who posts such answers that we are taking this forum seriously. Those downvotes are meant to discourage and to convey the message to seize and desist behaviour of such kind. _________ In more depth about this forum: There are essentially two types of questions, hard questions that asks about a specific problem, and requires a definite answer. On the other side there are soft questions like this one, asking about normative rules or "what if ..." type questions. In the first case, voting should be done based on the quality of the response (correctness, elaboration of the details at work, ...). This is already NOT DONE on SoloLearn, as posts are frequently(?) upvoted by followers from the activity feed (as I suspect), perhaps by people who cannot even judge the question, let alone the answers given. (Yes, that means, there shouldn't be any like-storms.) Answers that are wrong need to be downvoted to indicate issues with that suggested solution, those issues should also be pointed out then. For the soft question types, voting can reflect support for one opinion or the other; (s)he who wants to do so may use it as indication which ideas are popular, which ones are not. People posting off-topic should still be discouraged from doing so, a downvote reflecting lack of understanding the question or having nothing to contribute. But here, too, a downvote should not be given because one disagrees with an opinion. To sum up, any answer given should: - be a comment, asking for clarification or - an answer on topic Downvotes are not personal, they are not a means of revenge or punishment. They are to reflect to others (especially the OP) which answer is considered good and correct, by those who are qualified to pass that judgment, or contributing opinions. Off-topic responses and wrong answers are to be downvoted to indicate the opposite.

+12

We should tell them to stop spamming using a good approach🙂

+11

My standard post for this: "Please don't spam" + the post with the rules. Or I explain that the q&a section is only for programming related question. I think it is not wrong to downvote such posts but I would say that it is not nessecary. And in some cases the user only try out the q&a section. Sometimes they apologize then. But yesterday asked someone for a femdom. I downvoted this post. :D

+11

Sonic no hii messages not related to any programming But I does not recommend you to down vote just tell him to delete their answer Beacause for messages sololearn make a chatting system

+10

It's mentioned in the guidelines and I quote: "The Community chooses the best and the worst content/members using its right to upvote and downvote code samples, posts, answers, comments, etc. While an upvote is a reflection of one’s attitude to the content, a downvote is mainly used to keep SoloLearn safe and interesting. Here are the cases when the downvote is eligible: * Posts/answers comments that can be considered as spam * Incorrect and misleading answers * Answers/comments that do not match the question * Cases of plagiarism * Other cases that contradict the guidelines..." -- https://www.sololearn.com/Content-Creation-Guidelines/ Personally making them aware of their actions is better. Down-voting helps skip such posts, for others scrolling through the forum. Posts like this are removed regardless so either way is fine.

+9

Yes, if you believe it deserves a downvote go for it. It becomes bad if you downvote good or neutral comments, questions or codes.

+9

I don't downvote at all. Rather, I would tag the user and explain why I have an issue with the post. Downvotes are something done in the shadows, as the source of a downvote is not revealed. If a user posts something like "Hi" or "shejdhw" as an answer to a question I have asked, I post a response tagging them, and ask them "Please do not spam". I think this is better than a downvote, because I have personally called out their bad behavior. When I see a questioner asking such a person not to spam, I always upvote the questioners entreaty.

+8

I only downvote really bad behavior but never a badly answered question or a not so good code. Everyone benefits here, if it is clearly communicated what is good or bad on his code / contribution and what he could do better. But to look over the comments and to distribute his downvotes without comment definitely is bad behavior! Many will not know why and sensitive people won't post anymore. Of cause you can rate, but that should also be helpful for the other. An anonymous downvote is not helpful and indistinguishable from a malicious act!

+8

Honestly, it all depends. For example, if it is someone new, they may just not know that it shouldn't be done (I know a lot of people have said this already). I personally wouldn't downvote the comment for two reasons: one, it shows the kindness within the Sololearn community, preventing those inexperienced programmers to not be afraid to ask questions or post codes publicly; second, it also can show other new programmers that this shouldn't be done so that hopefully these events will become reduced and show up less and less. However, some other people may be spamming, and that is never good for forums and Q&As. To deal with this problem, I would probably look at the profile of the person who posted the comment first (as I know a lot of other people would do as well), and then decide whether the post deserves a downvote. Then again, it all depends on you and what you think you should do. P.S.: I'm also not saying these posts deserve downvotes! I just believe that upvotes and downvotes should be considered with thought before using either one on a post or comment.

+7

What I would like to downvote but don't because it seems to match the protocol: When people answer a question although it already has been answered and they are just saying the very same thing again. In the guidelines there's some part saying that misleading answers are to be downvoted. In my opinion this should be extended to obviously duplicate, spammy answers.

+7

I feel if it's worthy of reporting, it's worthy of downvoting. If we eliminate downvotes, we could probably also eliminate self-upvotes. Downvotes are only semi-anonymous in that platinum moderators can see which users have issued downvotes. Supposedly it's to prevent revenge-seeking behaviors. I'm not sure the downvote is a (dis)service to the poster as much as it's a service to others who may drop into the thread and sort by votes. On the other hand, upvotes seem to be a service to the poster more than a service to drop-ins for reasons already stated (users who post early and users with many followers who like storm get pushed up past more accurate or complete answers posted later on). So if you think it's spammy, feel free to both downvote and report. If you feel it's innocent infringement, you can take the gentler approach (warn & withhold vote). My 2c.

+7

Sonic I think that it is not good.Most users who posts stuffs like this are newbies and they don't know the rules.

+6

Paul K Sadler is right - why downvote at all? You can handle all purposes by upvoting, not voting, comments or, If there is the need reporting...

+6

I think you have to tag the person and explain to him his or her mistakes so that he or she does not repeat it again. sometimes down voting learners especially beginners makes them feel bored.so I think it's better to correct the person,That's my idea

+6

⚡Prometheus ⚡ I was talking more about those who say "Hi" as an answer to a question.

+5

I agree with Crash that upvoting, not upvoting, commenting and reporting can accomplish everything that a downvote can. I personally feel downvoting should be done away with. Short of that, it's shadowy nature should be eliminated by removing it's anonymous nature. This discourse is the beauty of this platform. We can all have our opinion. I thank you all for sharing yours.

+5

Downvoting is a bad thing, it demotivates newbies

+5

Latest rule of Sololearn: Never cross a moody MOD, lol.